Palumbo's Pizzeria

Discover Palumbo's Pizzeria in Tonawanda, NY, offering delicious pizza, wings, subs, and more. Enjoy affordable prices, a great buffet, and friendly management. Visit us at 1065 Sheridan Dr or call +1 716-332-1010 today!

Welcome to Palumbo's Pizzeria

Experience the finest dining

Palumbo's Pizzeria
Palumbo's Pizzeria
Palumbo's Pizzeria
Palumbo's Pizzeria

Palumbo's Pizzeria, a gem nestled at 1065 Sheridan Dr in Tonawanda, NY, offers a warm and inviting atmosphere for pizza lovers and families alike. The first bite of their signature pies transports you to a world of vibrant flavors. Known for value and variety, this restaurant combines affordable prices with outstanding taste, making it a local favorite. Whether dining in, taking out, or indulging in the delicious buffet, guests appreciate the attention to detail. The friendly management ensures a welcoming environment, fostering a sense of community among diners.

Palumbo's Pizzeria boasts an impressive menu featuring a variety of dishes that cater to every palate. First and foremost are the pizzas, available in both medium and large sizes. Each pie is crafted with fresh ingredients, resulting in a delightful homemade taste. The restaurant also offers a range of appetizing options such as crispy fries, battered mushrooms, and hearty salads. For wing enthusiasts, the 10 and 20 wing options are a popular choice, accompanied by sauces that range from mild to extra spicy.

Families enjoy the fair pricing, with average menu items hovering around $9.34.

The all-you-can-eat buffet stands out as a hit among patrons, allowing diners to sample multiple dishes at a reasonable price. This casual eatery welcomes all diners, whether they prefer a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a late-night snack. The friendly staff and vibrant atmosphere enhance every visit, making it more than just a meal—it's a community experience.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

1065 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150, United States

Phone

+1 716-332-1010

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Palumbo's Pizzeria
Palumbo's Pizzeria
Palumbo's Pizzeria
Palumbo's Pizzeria

Palumbo's Pizzeria caters to locals seeking a satisfying meal at an affordable price. Since its inception, it has been committed to providing fresh and delicious food. Each pizza is made from scratch using quality ingredients and traditional recipes, inviting customers to enjoy a hearty meal filled with rich flavors and comforting aromas. With an average price point that appeals to families and individuals alike, dining here provides excellent value without sacrificing quality.

From classic cheese pizzas to unique specialty pies, Palumbo's menu features something for everyone. The wings pair perfectly with the pizza for those who enjoy a little crunch in their meal.

With options for light eaters, such as large salads, everyone finds joy in the diverse offerings. The restaurant also shines with its appetizers, providing perfect starters for group gatherings. Customers rave about the jumbo chicken fingers and fried items, which bring a satisfying crunch to every bite.

Management takes pride in maintaining a friendly atmosphere, where customers feel known and appreciated. Regular patrons often witness the genuine connections formed between staff and diners. That sense of community shines through during local events, such as pizza-eating contests or wing challenges that bring people together for fun and food. Palumbo's Pizzeria truly represents the heart of Tonawanda, where flavor, friendship, and affordability unite.

Palumbo's Pizzeria

The exterior of Palumbo's Pizzeria captures the charm of a classic family-friendly restaurant. Bright signage and a welcoming entrance draw visitors in from the hustle of Sheridan Drive. The patio space, adorned with cheerful seating, offers the perfect spot for enjoying a sunny day over a slice of pizza. A casual vibe permeates the atmosphere, encouraging guests to relax and savor their meals. This inviting front creates a sense of instant connection, welcoming both regulars and newcomers alike.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday10 AM-3 PM
  • Tuesday10 AM-3 PM
  • Wednesday10 AM-3 PM
  • Thursday10 AM-3 PM
  • Friday10 AM-3 PM
  • SaturdayClosed

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

When I heard large cheese pepperoni was only $16.84 I was scared. Well, I was very very surprised how much I enjoyed this pizza. $16. Wow. Great value. Great cup n char. I enjoyed the sauce very much. Pizza was on the thinner side. Cooked well too. I enjoyed it very much. Thank you Only wish they had online ordering option

K
Kyle M.

So glad they are back open! Only place i know where you can pick and choose what you want for lunch! Fair prices, quick service

J
Jeff W.

If you want a good spot for pizza.....and like appetizers....this spot is a must. Amazing pizza and if you walk in you can get 1 of anything you want for a 1 piece price and it's already done. 1 wing.....1.09$ 1 jalapeno popper.....a buck. If u want a mott sick same thing. If u want a slice and one of each or even a pizza roll they have it. And it's ready to go. Must stop

P
Pc Z.

Absolutely love Palumbos! The only thing I don't like is that they're not open 24/7 I'm writing this review so upset I can't get their pizza right now and have to settle for some place else! I absolutely love the pizza, their subs , their prices & the owners & workers!! They're just really a great atmosphere with really good energy & even better food. They better not ever close!! You guys are awesome

M
Mary W.

The absolute best local pizza spot

J
James N.

First time trying today. Really good Buffalo pizza. Thick, chewy cheese, top tier cup'n'char pepperoni, mildly savory sauce. Place was clean when I came in, lady at the counter was very friendly. Overall, a good experience, will try again.

T
Tom M.